|

Excerpts from the Introduction
Over the years my writings have covered quite a few matters relevant to needs of the student or player or Baroque keyboards, especially those related to solo/soloist playing of the main middle-to-late-Baroque French and German keyboard repertoire. Some of those writings have received encouraging comments from internationally-renowned performers (such as Gustav Leonhardt and Igor Kipnis). Those essays and papers are now made available here in a convenient and inexpensive eBook form. Furthermore, they are not simply reprinted or translated: they have been fully revised, updated, expanded and additionally used as the backbone over which this new book has been written.
Finally, the musical examples have mostly been selected from works easily available in modern reprints, making it possible for the reader to check the few bars reprinted here against the full score.
The goal is to communicate ideas which I believe are significant and I have developed over decades of readings, performance, analysis and teaching, with no pretence of covering the vast field of Baroque keyboard performance.
worldwide ... a relatively uniform playing style has now developed, sometimes including manners that cannot be justified either as common Baroque practice or as the particular performance expected by the composer being played. This is one of the main issues the author has tried to address here. ... Though written mainly for the harpsichordist, this book is also addressed to the clavichordist and organist. ... and the differences between the three types of keyboard instruments are discussed.
Excerpts from the main Chapters
Some of the largest and best models of virginal produce a beautiful sound, slightly different but in no way inferior to that of a harpsichord.
All types of ancient instruments are being built again nowadays.

The only drawback of having a single manual instrument is that the player fails to develop the skills needed to play a two-manual one. But from an interpretation point of view
the
ideal general-purpose instrument
. The modern performer has to decide whether he prefers a 8'+4' or a 8'+8' instrument
Pros and cons of the two dispositions:
Should the harpsichordist purchase a finished instrument or build one from a "kit"? Some high-quality kits, when assembled by well-trained and dedicated amateurs, have proved to be excellent instruments
More often though
Drawings of the traditional jack's plucking and damping action often show as few as four stages.
the jack's action actually consists of as many as eleven distinct stages, as shown in the figure below
Wanda Landowska invented a playing technique
curving to a maximum the small phalanxes
we often read that J.S. Bach
curved the whole fingers
always leaving their keys by curving inwards
Which of the two ways should be considered the typical Baroque keyboard technique?
Legato, non-legato, detached and staccato
are quite precise in Baroque keyboards
it is paramount to establish which was the "basic" or "default" articulation.
in modern times there has always been significant disagreement on this matter: however, the historical evidence
Santa María (1557)
Nivers (1665)
Türk (1789)
Articulation and phrasing
Paradigm of Consistency
Inconsistency
Essential Ornaments
For most of the Baroque ornaments, the list of things
to check when playing, especially for beginners, is long but quite uniform: examples
accents
beat
length
speed

Baroque trills and mordents before the beat
Prof. Frederick Neumann's treatise on ornamentation makes fascinating reading. Perhaps less obvious is his tendency to
he leads the unsuspecting reader into agreeing with ademonstrablyerroneous solution.
the modern musician is now free to trill before or after the beat
Modern taste, Ancient taste and Bird Organs.
the many extant French-Baroque musical boxes show mercilessly
When facing a new French Baroque piece, even well-informed and experienced performers wonder:
1. Should I use inégales in this composer's music?
2. Should I play inégales in this particular piece?
3. Which notes should be inégales?
4. How inégales should they be?
5. Which passages should I single out for different degrees of inégalité?
Performing the inégales: CONSISTENCY
ARTICULATION
SLURS
DEGREE OF INEGALITÉ
SYMBOLS
DEFAULT INEQUALITY
FLEXIBILITY
STAGGERED INÉGALES
REGISTRATION
The conclusion is that slurred pairs in Baroque French music
The performance of inégales in Bach yields more than one uncertainty
Let us now review for inégales Bach's major harpsichord pieces
. there is a completely different-and in the author's opinion much more likely-interpretation of Rameau's "coulez pointées" conundrum.
Rameau merged both styles, featuring triplets in pieces with inégales. In the typical duplet+triplet+inégal situation the solution is simple
Baroque evidence for rubato ....
such an approach does not tell us how the ancient harpsichordists played, but rather how some modern musicians try to concoct general rules from obvious exceptions. In order to
get an adequate and authentic tempo for a piece, let us review three traditional and time-tested methods:
It has been said that the "préludes non mésurés" ... rank among the worst-performed pieces in modern times. Indeed, the variety of modern interpretation is bewildering
. The following is a suggested approach
Why would Corrette prescribe the upper 8' for the partition? Hubbard's explanation was that it is good advice because of
its slightly richer harmonic content
but
Corrette may have had another reason:
from the sources
we learn that 18th c. musicians were equally concerned with the two extremes: harpsichords quilled so lightly that they did not have enough loudness, or else quilled so loudly that their action was too heavy.
Today
in quite large halls
it is not unusual for otherwise fine replicas to sound decidedly too soft. Conversely, a very loud instrument
No Baroque source deals with harpsichord registration in any detail.
Had one asked, say, François Couperin
Even though direct evidence is rare, there is instead plenty of indirect evidence, and significant conclusions can be reached, as explained below.
The expressive use of the two manuals is employed by Bach in all the [six] possible ways:
The remainder of this chapter consists of the author's suggested double-manual registrations for some important works in the harpsichord Baroque repertoire.
REPERTOIRE ISSUES: This chapter is an attempt to clarify questions about the type of keyboard instrument intended in Baroque works, especially when the instrument was not clearly identified in the score
Was J.S. Bach a clavichordist or even a pianist?
Domenico Scarlatti
The keyboard range utilised in the Essercizi is chromatic AA-c'"....There are three alternative explanations
The best pieces that were ever written for the harpsichord.
. I also do that sometimes, replied Leonhardt
the famous Toccata and Fugue in d minor BWV565
a harpsichord work by J.P. Kellner?...
|